diff --git a/docs/implementation-gaps.md b/docs/implementation-gaps.md index b93d12c..b2b716b 100644 --- a/docs/implementation-gaps.md +++ b/docs/implementation-gaps.md @@ -28,13 +28,42 @@ This document identifies features specified in the documentation that are not ye - ✅ **Password Reset Flow**: Secure token-based password reset with Mailgun email service - ✅ **Email Verification System**: Full email verification with token validation and rate limiting - ✅ **Email Service Integration**: Mailgun API integration with templated emails +- ✅ **Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)**: TOTP and Email-based MFA with backup codes +- ✅ **Biometric Authentication**: Full WebAuthn/FIDO2 implementation for Face ID/Touch ID +- ✅ **Session Management**: Complete session tracking and revocation system +- ✅ **Device Trust Management**: Device registry with trust/revoke capabilities +- ✅ **Offline-First Redux Architecture**: Complete offline support with sync queue, optimistic updates, and conflict resolution +- ✅ **Daily Summary Dashboard** (October 2, 2025): Real-time activity counts with proper calculation for feeding, sleep, diaper, and medication tracking +- ✅ **Activities History Page** (October 2, 2025): Chronological view of last 7 days of activities with smart timestamps and color-coded icons +- ✅ **Sleep Duration Tracking** (October 2, 2025): Proper start/end time tracking with automatic duration calculation in daily summary ### Key Gaps Identified -- **Backend**: 42 features not implemented (12 completed ✅) -- **Frontend**: 36 features not implemented (2 completed ✅) +- **Backend**: 35 features not implemented (19 completed ✅) +- **Frontend**: 29 features not implemented (9 completed ✅) - **Infrastructure**: 18 features not implemented (3 completed ✅) - **Testing**: 15 features not implemented +### Top Priority Remaining Features + +**Critical (Must Fix Before Launch)**: +1. **Testing Foundation** - 0% test coverage, need 80%+ unit tests and integration tests +2. **COPPA/GDPR Compliance** - Data export API, account deletion workflow, consent management +3. **Redux Persist** - State persistence across page reloads (dependencies installed but not configured) +4. **Accessibility** - Screen reader support, keyboard navigation, WCAG AA compliance + +**High Priority (Pre-Launch)**: +1. **Real-Time Sync** - WebSocket room management for family activity sync +2. **AI Safety** - Medical disclaimer triggers, response moderation +3. **LangChain Context Management** - Token budget management, conversation memory +4. **Localization** - i18n setup for 5 languages (en, es, fr, pt, zh) +5. **Security Hardening** - CORS configuration, comprehensive input validation, XSS headers + +**Medium Priority (Post-Launch)**: +1. **GraphQL API** - Complex queries for dashboard optimization +2. **Voice Processing** - Whisper API integration, multi-language voice recognition +3. **Analytics & Predictions** - Pattern detection, ML-based next event predictions +4. **PWA Features** - Service worker configuration, offline pages, install prompts + --- ## 1. Backend API Implementation Gaps @@ -43,33 +72,38 @@ This document identifies features specified in the documentation that are not ye **Source**: `maternal-app-api-spec.md`, `maternal-app-env-config.md` -#### Missing Features +#### Completed Features ✅ -1. **Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)** - - Status: Not implemented - - Current: Basic JWT authentication only - - Needed: MFA support with TOTP/SMS for enhanced security +1. **Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** + - Current: Full MFA system with TOTP and Email-based authentication + - Implemented: MFA status endpoint, TOTP setup/enable/disable, Email MFA setup/send-code/verify, backup codes generation/regeneration, MFAService with complete flow + - Endpoints: GET /mfa/status, POST /mfa/totp/setup, POST /mfa/totp/enable, POST /mfa/email/setup, POST /mfa/email/send-code, POST /mfa/verify, DELETE /mfa, POST /mfa/backup-codes/regenerate - Priority: High - Impact: Security enhancement for sensitive child data -2. **Biometric Authentication Integration** - - Status: Not implemented - - Current: Password-only login - - Needed: Face ID / Touch ID / Fingerprint support +2. **Biometric Authentication Integration** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** + - Current: Full WebAuthn/FIDO2 biometric authentication + - Implemented: WebAuthn registration/verification, biometric authentication, credential management (list/delete/update), BiometricAuthService with complete flow + - Endpoints: POST /biometric/register/options, POST /biometric/register/verify, POST /biometric/authenticate/options, POST /biometric/authenticate/verify, GET /biometric/credentials, DELETE /biometric/credentials/:id, PATCH /biometric/credentials/:id, GET /biometric/has-credentials - Priority: High - Impact: Better UX for mobile, reduces login friction -3. **Device Trust Management UI** - - Status: Partial (backend exists) - - Current: Device fingerprinting stored but no management - - Needed: API endpoints to view/revoke trusted devices +3. **Device Trust Management** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** (Backend complete) + - Current: Full device registry and trust management system + - Implemented: Get all devices, get trusted devices, device count, trust/revoke device trust, remove devices, DeviceTrustService with complete API + - Endpoints: GET /devices, GET /devices/trusted, GET /devices/count, POST /devices/:id/trust, DELETE /devices/:id/trust, DELETE /devices/:id, DELETE /devices - Priority: Medium - Impact: Security and multi-device management + - Note: Frontend UI not yet implemented -4. **Session Management Endpoints** - - Status: Not implemented - - Current: No way to view active sessions - - Needed: GET /api/v1/auth/sessions, DELETE /api/v1/auth/sessions/:id +4. **Session Management Endpoints** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** + - Current: Complete session management system + - Implemented: Get all sessions, session count, revoke single session, revoke all sessions, SessionService with token tracking + - Endpoints: GET /sessions, GET /sessions/count, DELETE /sessions/:id, DELETE /sessions - Priority: Medium - Impact: Security control for users @@ -372,45 +406,54 @@ This document identifies features specified in the documentation that are not ye **Source**: `maternal-app-state-management.md` -1. **Redux Toolkit Offline Support** - - Status: Redux installed but offline middleware missing - - Current: Basic Redux store - - Needed: redux-offline, sync queue, conflict resolution +#### Completed Features ✅ + +1. **Redux Toolkit Offline Support** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** + - Current: Full offline-first architecture with custom middleware + - Implemented: offlineMiddleware for action queuing, syncMiddleware for auto-sync, network detection (browser events + periodic /api/health checks), pendingActions queue with retry logic (max 5 retries) + - Files: store/middleware/offlineMiddleware.ts, store/middleware/syncMiddleware.ts, store/slices/offlineSlice.ts - Priority: High - Impact: Core offline-first requirement -2. **Normalized State Shape** - - Status: Not implemented - - Current: Direct API response storage - - Needed: Entities with byId/allIds structure +2. **Normalized State Shape** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** + - Current: Redux Toolkit EntityAdapter with normalized structure + - Implemented: createEntityAdapter for activities, byId/allIds structure, automatic sorting by timestamp, efficient lookups + - Files: store/slices/activitiesSlice.ts - Priority: High - Impact: Performance and data consistency -3. **Optimistic Updates** - - Status: Not implemented - - Current: Wait for server response - - Needed: Immediate UI updates with rollback +3. **Optimistic Updates** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** + - Current: Full optimistic update system with rollback + - Implemented: optimisticCreate/Update/Delete actions, automatic rollback on API failure, _optimistic flag tracking, _version tracking for conflict detection + - Files: store/slices/activitiesSlice.ts (lines 117-153) - Priority: High - Impact: Perceived performance -4. **Sync Middleware** - - Status: Not implemented - - Current: No sync queue - - Needed: Queue offline actions, process when online +4. **Sync Middleware** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** + - Current: Automatic sync when connection restored + - Implemented: syncMiddleware processes pending actions sequentially, exponential retry logic, sync status tracking (idle/syncing/synced/error) + - Files: store/middleware/syncMiddleware.ts - Priority: High - Impact: Offline functionality -5. **Conflict Resolution Strategy** - - Status: Not implemented - - Current: Last write only - - Needed: Version-based merge, user confirmation +5. **Conflict Resolution Strategy** ✅ COMPLETED + - Status: **IMPLEMENTED** + - Current: Multiple conflict resolution strategies + - Implemented: 4 strategies (SERVER_WINS, CLIENT_WINS, LAST_WRITE_WINS, MERGE), version-based conflict detection, timestamp comparison, hasConflict() helper + - Files: store/middleware/syncMiddleware.ts (lines 72-129) - Priority: Medium - Impact: Data integrity in multi-user scenarios +#### Remaining Features + 6. **Redux Persist Configuration** - - Status: redux-persist installed but not configured - - Current: No persistence - - Needed: Persist auth, activities, children slices + - Status: Not configured + - Current: State lost on page reload + - Needed: Persist auth, activities, children, offline slices to localStorage - Priority: High - Impact: App state across restarts @@ -1145,11 +1188,11 @@ This document identifies features specified in the documentation that are not ye ### Summary Statistics - **Total Gaps Identified**: 120 features - - **Completed**: 17 features ✅ (14.2%) - - **Remaining**: 103 features -- **Critical Priority**: 18 features (2 completed ✅) -- **High Priority**: 35 features (11 completed ✅) -- **Medium Priority**: 42 features (4 completed ✅) + - **Completed**: 30 features ✅ (25%) + - **Remaining**: 90 features +- **Critical Priority**: 18 features (8 completed ✅) +- **High Priority**: 35 features (16 completed ✅) +- **Medium Priority**: 42 features (6 completed ✅) - **Low Priority**: 25 features (0 completed) ### Key Observations @@ -1168,8 +1211,16 @@ This document identifies features specified in the documentation that are not ye - Loading states with 15+ skeleton components - Password reset and email verification flows - Email service with Mailgun integration + - Multi-Factor Authentication (TOTP + Email) + - Biometric authentication (WebAuthn/FIDO2) + - Session management with revocation + - Device trust management system + - **Offline-first Redux architecture** (sync queue, optimistic updates, conflict resolution) + - **Daily summary dashboard** (October 2): Real activity counts with medicine tracker + - **Activities history page** (October 2): 7-day activity timeline view + - **Sleep duration tracking** (October 2): Automatic duration calculation from start/end times -3. **Missing Critical Features**: Offline-first functionality, password reset, email verification, and remaining compliance features are the most critical gaps. +3. **Missing Critical Features**: Compliance features (COPPA/GDPR) and testing are the most critical remaining gaps. 4. **AI Needs Work**: The AI module exists but lacks safety features, context management, and multi-language support. @@ -1177,15 +1228,15 @@ This document identifies features specified in the documentation that are not ye 6. **Accessibility Gaps**: No evidence of accessibility testing or screen reader support. -7. **Security Hardening**: Basic authentication exists, error handling improved ✅, rate limiting implemented ✅, prompt injection protection added ✅, but still lacks MFA and comprehensive validation. +7. **Security Hardening**: Strong authentication system ✅ (MFA, biometric, session management, device trust), error handling improved ✅, rate limiting implemented ✅, prompt injection protection added ✅, but still needs comprehensive input validation and CORS configuration. ### Next Steps -1. **Prioritize offline-first implementation** - This is documented as a core requirement but not implemented -2. **Add error handling and logging** - Critical for production debugging -3. **Implement compliance features** - Legal requirement for launch -4. **Write tests** - Critical for code quality and maintainability -5. **Add accessibility features** - Legal requirement and good practice +1. **Implement compliance features** - Legal requirement for launch (COPPA/GDPR data export/deletion, consent management) +2. **Write tests** - Critical for code quality and maintainability (currently 0% coverage, target 80%) +3. **Add accessibility features** - Legal requirement and good practice (WCAG AA compliance, screen readers, keyboard nav) +4. **Configure Redux Persist** - State persistence across page reloads (dependencies installed but not configured) +5. **Frontend UI for auth features** - Backend complete for MFA/biometric/sessions/devices, need user-facing UI ### Documentation Quality