andrei/maternal-app
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
537e5d7823aeca161220d1e91c950e7f44efe02e
maternal-app/docs/implementation-gaps.md
Andrei 537e5d7823
Some checks failed
CI/CD Pipeline / Lint and Test (push) Has been cancelled
Details
CI/CD Pipeline / E2E Tests (push) Has been cancelled
Details
CI/CD Pipeline / Build Application (push) Has been cancelled
Details
Update implementation gaps with daily summary and activities features 
- Mark daily summary dashboard as completed (October 2, 2025)
- Mark activities history page as completed (October 2, 2025)
- Mark sleep duration tracking as completed (October 2, 2025)
- Update statistics: 30/120 features completed (25%)
- Add top priority remaining features summary section
- Reorganize critical/high/medium priority items for clarity

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
2025-10-02 14:49:24 +00:00

43 KiB
Raw Blame History

Implementation Gaps Analysis - Maternal App

Generated: October 1, 2024 Status: Documentation vs Implementation Comparison

This document identifies features specified in the documentation that are not yet fully implemented but would improve the current system. Items are categorized by priority and organized by functional area.

Executive Summary

Implementation Status

  • Backend Modules Implemented: Auth, Children, Families, Tracking, Voice, AI, Analytics, Notifications, Feedback, Photos ✅
  • Frontend Pages Implemented: Dashboard, Auth, Children, Family, Tracking (Feeding/Sleep/Diaper), AI Assistant, Analytics, Insights, History, Settings
  • Database Entities: User, Family, Child, Activity, DeviceRegistry, RefreshToken, AIConversation, AuditLog ✅, Photo ✅

Recent Additions (October 2025)

  • ✅ Photo Management System: Full photo upload, storage, optimization, and gallery features
  • ✅ Error Code Standardization: 80+ error codes with 5-language localization
  • ✅ Redis Caching Layer: User, child, family, analytics, and query result caching
  • ✅ Performance Monitoring: Request duration tracking and slow query detection
  • ✅ Audit Logging: Comprehensive audit trail for compliance
  • ✅ Performance Indexes: Optimized database queries with composite indexes
  • ✅ Rate Limiting: Custom Next.js rate limiter with 5 endpoint configurations
  • ✅ Prompt Injection Protection: 25+ security patterns with input sanitization
  • ✅ Voice Intent Classification: Pattern-based NLP with entity extraction
  • ✅ Loading States: Skeleton screens across all pages for better UX
  • ✅ Password Reset Flow: Secure token-based password reset with Mailgun email service
  • ✅ Email Verification System: Full email verification with token validation and rate limiting
  • ✅ Email Service Integration: Mailgun API integration with templated emails
  • ✅ Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): TOTP and Email-based MFA with backup codes
  • ✅ Biometric Authentication: Full WebAuthn/FIDO2 implementation for Face ID/Touch ID
  • ✅ Session Management: Complete session tracking and revocation system
  • ✅ Device Trust Management: Device registry with trust/revoke capabilities
  • ✅ Offline-First Redux Architecture: Complete offline support with sync queue, optimistic updates, and conflict resolution
  • ✅ Daily Summary Dashboard (October 2, 2025): Real-time activity counts with proper calculation for feeding, sleep, diaper, and medication tracking
  • ✅ Activities History Page (October 2, 2025): Chronological view of last 7 days of activities with smart timestamps and color-coded icons
  • ✅ Sleep Duration Tracking (October 2, 2025): Proper start/end time tracking with automatic duration calculation in daily summary

Key Gaps Identified

  • Backend: 35 features not implemented (19 completed ✅)
  • Frontend: 29 features not implemented (9 completed ✅)
  • Infrastructure: 18 features not implemented (3 completed ✅)
  • Testing: 15 features not implemented

Top Priority Remaining Features

Critical (Must Fix Before Launch):

  1. Testing Foundation - 0% test coverage, need 80%+ unit tests and integration tests
  2. COPPA/GDPR Compliance - Data export API, account deletion workflow, consent management
  3. Redux Persist - State persistence across page reloads (dependencies installed but not configured)
  4. Accessibility - Screen reader support, keyboard navigation, WCAG AA compliance

High Priority (Pre-Launch):

  1. Real-Time Sync - WebSocket room management for family activity sync
  2. AI Safety - Medical disclaimer triggers, response moderation
  3. LangChain Context Management - Token budget management, conversation memory
  4. Localization - i18n setup for 5 languages (en, es, fr, pt, zh)
  5. Security Hardening - CORS configuration, comprehensive input validation, XSS headers

Medium Priority (Post-Launch):

  1. GraphQL API - Complex queries for dashboard optimization
  2. Voice Processing - Whisper API integration, multi-language voice recognition
  3. Analytics & Predictions - Pattern detection, ML-based next event predictions
  4. PWA Features - Service worker configuration, offline pages, install prompts

1. Backend API Implementation Gaps

1.1 Authentication & Security (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md, maternal-app-env-config.md

Completed Features ✅

  1. Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Full MFA system with TOTP and Email-based authentication
    • Implemented: MFA status endpoint, TOTP setup/enable/disable, Email MFA setup/send-code/verify, backup codes generation/regeneration, MFAService with complete flow
    • Endpoints: GET /mfa/status, POST /mfa/totp/setup, POST /mfa/totp/enable, POST /mfa/email/setup, POST /mfa/email/send-code, POST /mfa/verify, DELETE /mfa, POST /mfa/backup-codes/regenerate
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Security enhancement for sensitive child data

  2. Biometric Authentication Integration ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Full WebAuthn/FIDO2 biometric authentication
    • Implemented: WebAuthn registration/verification, biometric authentication, credential management (list/delete/update), BiometricAuthService with complete flow
    • Endpoints: POST /biometric/register/options, POST /biometric/register/verify, POST /biometric/authenticate/options, POST /biometric/authenticate/verify, GET /biometric/credentials, DELETE /biometric/credentials/:id, PATCH /biometric/credentials/:id, GET /biometric/has-credentials
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Better UX for mobile, reduces login friction

  3. Device Trust Management ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED (Backend complete)
    • Current: Full device registry and trust management system
    • Implemented: Get all devices, get trusted devices, device count, trust/revoke device trust, remove devices, DeviceTrustService with complete API
    • Endpoints: GET /devices, GET /devices/trusted, GET /devices/count, POST /devices/:id/trust, DELETE /devices/:id/trust, DELETE /devices/:id, DELETE /devices
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Security and multi-device management
    • Note: Frontend UI not yet implemented

  4. Session Management Endpoints ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Complete session management system
    • Implemented: Get all sessions, session count, revoke single session, revoke all sessions, SessionService with token tracking
    • Endpoints: GET /sessions, GET /sessions/count, DELETE /sessions/:id, DELETE /sessions
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Security control for users

  5. Password Reset Flow ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Full password reset system with secure tokens
    • Implemented: Token generation (1hr expiry), email service (Mailgun), API endpoints (/password/forgot, /password/reset), PasswordResetToken entity, security features (rate limiting, token validation)
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Critical for user recovery

  6. Email Verification System ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Full email verification system
    • Implemented: Token generation (24hr expiry), verification emails, API endpoints (/email/send-verification, /email/verify, /email/resend-verification), rate limiting (2min between sends), emailVerified flag tracking
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Account security and COPPA compliance

1.2 GraphQL Implementation (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md, maternal-app-tech-stack.md

  1. GraphQL Endpoint

    • Status: Dependencies installed (@nestjs/graphql) but not configured
    • Current: REST API only
    • Needed: GraphQL endpoint at /graphql with schema
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Efficient complex data fetching for dashboard

  2. GraphQL Subscriptions

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: WebSocket for real-time sync
    • Needed: GraphQL subscriptions for real-time data
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Alternative real-time implementation

  3. Complex Dashboard Queries

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Multiple REST calls for dashboard data
    • Needed: Single GraphQL query for entire dashboard
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Performance optimization, reduced API calls

1.3 AI & LangChain Features (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-ai-context.md, maternal-app-voice-processing.md

  1. LangChain Context Management

    • Status: Basic AI implementation exists
    • Current: Simple prompt/response without context prioritization
    • Needed: Token budget management (4000 tokens), priority weighting system
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Better AI responses with relevant context

  2. Conversation Memory System

    • Status: AIConversation entity exists but no memory management
    • Current: Each query is independent
    • Needed: Conversation summarization, context retrieval
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Coherent multi-turn conversations

  3. Personalization Engine

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Generic responses for all users
    • Needed: Learning from feedback, user preference adaptation
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Tailored AI responses per user

  4. Medical Disclaimer Triggers

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No safety boundaries
    • Needed: Keyword detection for medical concerns, crisis hotline integration
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Critical safety feature

  5. Multi-Language AI Responses

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: English only
    • Needed: Localized prompts for 5 languages (en, es, fr, pt, zh)
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: International user support

  6. Prompt Injection Protection ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Comprehensive security system with 25+ regex patterns
    • Implemented: System manipulation detection, role change blocking, data exfiltration prevention, command injection filters, input validation (length, character analysis), rate limiting (5 suspicious attempts/min)
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Security vulnerability mitigation

1.4 Voice Processing (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-app-voice-processing.md

  1. Whisper API Integration

    • Status: Voice module exists but implementation unclear
    • Current: Basic voice endpoint
    • Needed: OpenAI Whisper transcription with confidence scoring
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Core hands-free feature

  2. Multi-Language Voice Recognition

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No language detection
    • Needed: Support for 5 languages with automatic detection
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: International accessibility

  3. Intent Classification System ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Pattern-based classifier with confidence scoring
    • Implemented: Feeding/sleep/diaper intent detection, 25 test cases passing, structured data output
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Accurate command interpretation

  4. Entity Extraction ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Comprehensive entity extraction from voice input
    • Implemented: Extract amounts (ml, oz), durations (minutes, hours), times (now, ago), breast sides (left/right), diaper types (wet/dirty/both)
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Data quality from voice input

  5. Offline Voice Fallback

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No offline support
    • Needed: Device native speech recognition fallback
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Offline functionality

  6. Voice Command Error Recovery

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No clarification mechanism
    • Needed: Common mishear corrections, clarification prompts
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: User experience improvement

1.5 Analytics & Predictions (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md, maternal-app-state-management.md

  1. Pattern Detection Algorithms

    • Status: Prediction service exists but algorithms unclear
    • Current: Basic analytics
    • Needed: Sleep regression detection, feeding pattern analysis
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Valuable insights for parents

  2. Next Event Predictions

    • Status: Partial implementation
    • Current: Basic prediction endpoint
    • Needed: ML-based nap time, feeding time predictions with confidence scores
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Proactive parenting support

  3. Growth Spurt Detection

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No pattern analysis
    • Needed: Likelihood calculation based on feeding/sleep changes
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Helpful parenting insights

  4. Weekly/Monthly Reports

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No automated reporting
    • Needed: Scheduled report generation with trends
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Long-term tracking

1.6 Real-Time Features (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md

  1. WebSocket Room Management

    • Status: Socket.io installed but room logic unclear
    • Current: Basic WebSocket connection
    • Needed: Family room join/leave, presence indicators
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Real-time family sync

  2. Typing Indicators

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No real-time feedback
    • Needed: Show when family member is logging activity
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Better collaboration awareness

  3. Active Timer Sync

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No cross-device timer sync
    • Needed: Real-time timer events across devices
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Prevents duplicate logging

  4. Connection Recovery

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Basic connection
    • Needed: Exponential backoff reconnection strategy
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Reliability in poor networks

1.7 Database & Performance (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-app-db-migrations.md

  1. Table Partitioning

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Single activities table
    • Needed: Monthly partitions for activities
    • Priority: Low (only needed at scale)
    • Impact: Performance for large datasets

  2. Audit Logging Tables ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED (V006)
    • Current: audit_log table created with proper indexes
    • Implemented: Full audit logging with event tracking, user actions, metadata
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Legal compliance requirement

  3. Notification Scheduling

    • Status: Notifications module exists but scheduling unclear
    • Current: Basic notifications
    • Needed: scheduled_notifications table, cron job processing
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Proactive reminders

  4. Pattern/Prediction Tables

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No persistence of patterns
    • Needed: patterns and predictions tables with expiration
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Historical analysis

  5. Performance Indexes ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED (V009)
    • Current: Comprehensive indexes on all major tables
    • Implemented: Composite indexes for common queries, partial indexes for recent data
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Query performance

  6. Data Deletion Requests Table

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No GDPR deletion tracking
    • Needed: data_deletion_requests table
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: GDPR compliance

1.8 File Storage & Media (LOW Priority)

Source: maternal-app-tech-stack.md, maternal-app-env-config.md

  1. MinIO Integration ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED (V008)
    • Current: Full MinIO integration with S3-compatible API
    • Implemented: Photo upload, presigned URLs, storage service
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Profile personalization

  2. Image Processing ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Sharp-based image optimization
    • Implemented: Automatic resizing (1920x1920), quality optimization (85%), thumbnail generation (300x300)
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Performance and storage efficiency

  3. Photo Milestones ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED (V008)
    • Current: Full photo tracking system
    • Implemented: Photo uploads with timestamps, activity/milestone association, gallery views, stats
    • Priority: Low (post-MVP)
    • Impact: Memory keeping feature

1.9 External Integrations (LOW Priority)

Source: maternal-app-tech-stack.md, maternal-app-api-spec.md

  1. Email Service Integration ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Full Mailgun email service
    • Implemented: EmailService with Mailgun API, password reset emails, email verification emails, templated HTML emails, error handling and logging
    • Priority: High (for email verification)
    • Impact: User onboarding

  2. Push Notifications Service

    • Status: Notifications module exists but FCM not integrated
    • Current: Basic notification endpoints
    • Needed: Firebase Cloud Messaging integration
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Mobile engagement

  3. Calendar Integration

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No calendar sync
    • Needed: Google Calendar, Apple Calendar integration
    • Priority: Low (post-MVP)
    • Impact: External scheduling

2. Frontend Implementation Gaps

2.1 State Management (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-state-management.md

Completed Features ✅

  1. Redux Toolkit Offline Support ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Full offline-first architecture with custom middleware
    • Implemented: offlineMiddleware for action queuing, syncMiddleware for auto-sync, network detection (browser events + periodic /api/health checks), pendingActions queue with retry logic (max 5 retries)
    • Files: store/middleware/offlineMiddleware.ts, store/middleware/syncMiddleware.ts, store/slices/offlineSlice.ts
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Core offline-first requirement

  2. Normalized State Shape ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Redux Toolkit EntityAdapter with normalized structure
    • Implemented: createEntityAdapter for activities, byId/allIds structure, automatic sorting by timestamp, efficient lookups
    • Files: store/slices/activitiesSlice.ts
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Performance and data consistency

  3. Optimistic Updates ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Full optimistic update system with rollback
    • Implemented: optimisticCreate/Update/Delete actions, automatic rollback on API failure, _optimistic flag tracking, _version tracking for conflict detection
    • Files: store/slices/activitiesSlice.ts (lines 117-153)
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Perceived performance

  4. Sync Middleware ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Automatic sync when connection restored
    • Implemented: syncMiddleware processes pending actions sequentially, exponential retry logic, sync status tracking (idle/syncing/synced/error)
    • Files: store/middleware/syncMiddleware.ts
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Offline functionality

  5. Conflict Resolution Strategy ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Multiple conflict resolution strategies
    • Implemented: 4 strategies (SERVER_WINS, CLIENT_WINS, LAST_WRITE_WINS, MERGE), version-based conflict detection, timestamp comparison, hasConflict() helper
    • Files: store/middleware/syncMiddleware.ts (lines 72-129)
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Data integrity in multi-user scenarios

Remaining Features

  1. Redux Persist Configuration
    • Status: Not configured
    • Current: State lost on page reload
    • Needed: Persist auth, activities, children, offline slices to localStorage
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: App state across restarts

2.2 Real-Time Features (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md

  1. WebSocket Client

    • Status: socket.io-client installed but not configured
    • Current: No real-time sync
    • Needed: Family room connection, activity sync events
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Family collaboration

  2. Live Activity Updates

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Manual refresh
    • Needed: Auto-update on family member actions
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Real-time awareness

  3. Presence Indicators

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No online status
    • Needed: Show which family members are online
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Collaboration awareness

2.3 AI Assistant UI (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-ai-context.md, maternal-app-design-system.md

  1. Streaming Responses

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Wait for full response
    • Needed: Token-by-token streaming display
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Perceived speed

  2. Conversation History

    • Status: Basic chat UI exists
    • Current: Single query/response
    • Needed: Scrollable conversation history
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Context for parents

  3. Suggested Follow-Ups

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Manual typing only
    • Needed: Quick reply buttons based on context
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Ease of use

  4. Voice Input Button ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Full voice input UI with Web Speech API
    • Implemented: VoiceFloatingButton (FAB), VoiceInputButton component, useVoiceInput hook, real-time transcription, auto-classification, form auto-fill integration
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Hands-free feature

  5. AI Response Feedback

    • Status: Feedback API exists but no UI
    • Current: No rating mechanism
    • Needed: Thumbs up/down, improvement suggestions
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: AI improvement loop

2.4 Accessibility Features (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-design-system.md, maternal-app-testing-strategy.md

  1. Screen Reader Support

    • Status: Not verified
    • Current: Unknown
    • Needed: ARIA labels, semantic HTML, screen reader testing
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: WCAG AA compliance

  2. Keyboard Navigation

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Mouse/touch only
    • Needed: Full keyboard navigation with focus indicators
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Accessibility requirement

  3. High Contrast Mode

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Single color scheme
    • Needed: High contrast theme for vision impairment
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Accessibility enhancement

  4. Text Scaling Support

    • Status: Not verified
    • Current: Fixed font sizes
    • Needed: Responsive text scaling (up to 200%)
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Accessibility requirement

  5. Reduced Motion Support

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Animations enabled
    • Needed: Respect prefers-reduced-motion media query
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Accessibility for vestibular disorders

2.5 Progressive Web App (PWA) (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-web/package.json (next-pwa installed)

  1. Service Worker Configuration

    • Status: next-pwa installed but not configured
    • Current: No offline capability
    • Needed: Service worker for offline pages, caching
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Offline-first web experience

  2. Install Prompts

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Browser only
    • Needed: Add-to-home-screen prompts
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Mobile-like experience

  3. Background Sync

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No background processing
    • Needed: Sync when app reopens from background
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Seamless sync

  4. Push Notification Permission

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No web push
    • Needed: Browser push notification support
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Engagement

2.6 Localization (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md, maternal-app-ai-context.md

  1. i18n Framework Setup

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Hardcoded English strings
    • Needed: i18next integration, language files
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: International user support

  2. Language Files

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No translation files
    • Needed: JSON files for 5 languages (en, es, fr, pt, zh)
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Multi-language support

  3. Date/Time Localization

    • Status: date-fns installed but not fully localized
    • Current: US format only
    • Needed: Locale-aware date/time formatting
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: International UX

  4. Measurement Unit Conversion

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Fixed units
    • Needed: Imperial/Metric conversion based on locale
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: International usability

2.7 Design System Implementation (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-app-design-system.md

  1. Material Design Components

    • Status: MUI installed but custom components needed
    • Current: Basic MUI components
    • Needed: Custom themed components matching design spec
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Visual consistency

  2. Dark Mode

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Light mode only
    • Needed: Dark theme variant, system preference detection
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: User preference

  3. One-Handed Operation Zones

    • Status: Not verified
    • Current: Unknown layout
    • Needed: Critical actions in bottom 60% of screen
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Mobile usability

  4. Touch Target Sizes

    • Status: Not verified
    • Current: Unknown
    • Needed: Minimum 44x44px touch targets (iOS HIG)
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Mobile accessibility

  5. Loading States & Skeletons ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Comprehensive skeleton screen system
    • Implemented: LoadingSkeletons.tsx with 15+ components (ActivityCardSkeleton, StatGridSkeleton, FormSkeleton, ChartSkeleton, etc.), integrated across dashboard, analytics, tracking pages (feeding/sleep/diaper)
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Perceived performance

  6. Error Boundaries

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: App crashes on errors
    • Needed: React error boundaries with recovery UI
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: App stability

3. Infrastructure & DevOps Gaps

3.1 Monitoring & Logging (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-error-logging.md, maternal-app-env-config.md

  1. Sentry Integration ✅ PARTIALLY COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED (ErrorTrackingService)
    • Current: Sentry integration with error categorization and fingerprinting
    • Implemented: Error tracking service with context, tags, and severity levels
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Production error tracking

  2. Structured Logging

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: console.log statements
    • Needed: Winston with JSON format, log levels
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Production debugging

  3. Performance Monitoring ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: PerformanceInterceptor with request duration tracking
    • Implemented: Request duration logging, slow query detection (>1s threshold)
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Performance optimization

  4. Error Code System ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Comprehensive error code system with 80+ error codes
    • Implemented: Standardized error codes (AUTH_, USER_, VALIDATION_*, etc.), multi-language error messages (5 languages)
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Consistent error handling

  5. PII Sanitization

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No data filtering
    • Needed: Remove sensitive data from logs
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Privacy compliance

3.2 Testing Infrastructure (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-testing-strategy.md

  1. Unit Test Suite

    • Status: Jest configured but no tests written
    • Current: 0% coverage
    • Needed: 80% code coverage target
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Code quality and reliability

  2. Integration Tests

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No API testing
    • Needed: Supertest-based endpoint testing
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: API reliability

  3. E2E Tests

    • Status: Playwright installed (frontend) but no tests
    • Current: No end-to-end testing
    • Needed: Critical user journey tests
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Feature validation

  4. Mock Data Generators

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No test data utilities
    • Needed: Realistic test data generation functions
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Test quality

  5. CI/CD Pipeline

    • Status: GitHub Actions configured but minimal
    • Current: No automated testing
    • Needed: Test, lint, build pipeline
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Code quality enforcement

  6. Performance Testing

    • Status: Artillery config exists but not integrated
    • Current: No load testing
    • Needed: Automated load tests with thresholds
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Scalability validation

3.3 Deployment & Operations (MEDIUM Priority)

Source: maternal-app-mobile-deployment.md, maternal-app-env-config.md

  1. Environment Configuration

    • Status: Basic .env files
    • Current: Development only
    • Needed: Staging and production environment configs
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Deployment readiness

  2. Secret Management

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Plain text .env files
    • Needed: AWS Secrets Manager / Vault integration
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Production security

  3. Docker Production Images

    • Status: Docker Compose for development
    • Current: Dev containers only
    • Needed: Optimized production Dockerfiles
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Deployment efficiency

  4. Health Check Endpoints

    • Status: HealthController exists
    • Current: Basic health check
    • Needed: Comprehensive health checks (DB, Redis, external APIs)
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Monitoring and orchestration

  5. Database Backup Strategy

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No backups
    • Needed: Automated PostgreSQL backups with retention
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Data protection

  6. Blue-Green Deployment

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No deployment strategy
    • Needed: Zero-downtime deployment process
    • Priority: Low
    • Impact: Production updates

3.4 Mobile Build & Distribution (LOW Priority - Post-MVP)

Source: maternal-app-mobile-deployment.md

  1. iOS Provisioning

    • Status: Not configured
    • Current: Development only
    • Needed: App Store certificates, provisioning profiles
    • Priority: Low (post-MVP)
    • Impact: iOS release

  2. Android Signing

    • Status: Not configured
    • Current: Debug builds only
    • Needed: Release keystore, Play Store configuration
    • Priority: Low (post-MVP)
    • Impact: Android release

  3. Fastlane Configuration

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Manual builds
    • Needed: Automated build and deployment lanes
    • Priority: Low (post-MVP)
    • Impact: Release automation

  4. TestFlight Setup

    • Status: Not configured
    • Current: No beta distribution
    • Needed: TestFlight groups, metadata
    • Priority: Low (post-MVP)
    • Impact: Beta testing

  5. CodePush OTA Updates

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Full app updates only
    • Needed: Over-the-air update capability
    • Priority: Low (post-MVP)
    • Impact: Quick bug fixes

4. Compliance & Security Gaps

4.1 COPPA Compliance (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md, maternal-app-error-logging.md

  1. Age Verification

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No age checks
    • Needed: Age verification before child profile creation
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Legal requirement for US

  2. Parental Consent Flow

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No consent tracking
    • Needed: Explicit consent for data collection
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Legal compliance

  3. Data Minimization

    • Status: Not enforced
    • Current: Full data collection
    • Needed: Only collect necessary data fields
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Privacy best practice

4.2 GDPR Compliance (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md, maternal-app-db-migrations.md

  1. Data Export

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No data portability
    • Needed: Export all user data in JSON format
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: GDPR right to data portability

  2. Right to Deletion

    • Status: Soft deletes exist but no API
    • Current: No deletion workflow
    • Needed: User-initiated account deletion with 30-day grace period
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: GDPR right to erasure

  3. Consent Management

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No consent tracking
    • Needed: Granular consent for data processing purposes
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: GDPR consent requirement

  4. Audit Trail

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: No access logging
    • Needed: Audit log for all data access
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: GDPR accountability

4.3 Security Hardening (HIGH Priority)

Source: maternal-app-api-spec.md, maternal-app-tech-stack.md

  1. Rate Limiting ✅ COMPLETED

    • Status: IMPLEMENTED
    • Current: Custom Next.js-native rate limiter
    • Implemented: In-memory Map-based storage, 5 endpoint configurations (auth: 5/15min, AI: 10/hr, tracking: 30/min, read: 100/min, sensitive: 3/hr), 429 responses with Retry-After headers
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: DDoS protection

  2. Request Validation

    • Status: class-validator installed but not comprehensive
    • Current: Basic validation
    • Needed: Comprehensive input validation on all endpoints
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Security and data quality

  3. CORS Configuration

    • Status: Not configured
    • Current: Default CORS
    • Needed: Strict origin whitelisting
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: XSS protection

  4. SQL Injection Prevention

    • Status: TypeORM provides protection
    • Current: ORM-based
    • Needed: Verify all raw queries are parameterized
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Security critical

  5. XSS Protection Headers

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Default headers
    • Needed: Helmet.js with strict CSP
    • Priority: High
    • Impact: Web security

  6. Data Encryption at Rest

    • Status: Not implemented
    • Current: Plain text in database
    • Needed: Encrypt sensitive fields (medical info, notes)
    • Priority: Medium
    • Impact: Privacy enhancement

5. Feature Gaps (Post-MVP)

Note: These are documented features explicitly marked as post-MVP that are correctly not implemented yet.

5.1 Community Features (Post-MVP)

Source: CLAUDE.md - Deferred Features

  • Community forums with moderation
  • Parent-to-parent messaging
  • Support groups by age/topic
  • Expert Q&A sessions

5.2 Advanced Tracking (Post-MVP)

Source: CLAUDE.md - Future Roadmap

  • Meal planning and nutrition tracking
  • Financial tracking (childcare expenses)
  • Medication scheduling with reminders
  • Temperature tracking with fever alerts
  • Growth charts with WHO percentiles

5.3 Integrations (Post-MVP)

Source: CLAUDE.md, maternal-app-tech-stack.md

  • Smart home integration (Alexa, Google Home)
  • Calendar sync (Google, Apple, Outlook)
  • School platform integrations
  • Telemedicine integration
  • Health app sync (Apple Health, Google Fit)

5.4 Premium Features (Post-MVP)

  • Advanced AI insights
  • Unlimited AI queries
  • Custom reports and exports
  • Professional caregiver tools
  • Video consultations

6. Priority Matrix

Critical (Must Fix Before Launch)

  1. Offline-First Architecture (Frontend + Backend)

    • Redux offline middleware
    • Sync queue implementation
    • Conflict resolution
    • Impact: Core feature requirement

  2. Authentication Security (Backend)

    • Password reset
    • Email verification
    • Device management
    • Impact: User security

  3. Error Handling (Backend + Frontend)

    • Standardized error codes
    • Error boundaries
    • Proper HTTP status codes
    • Impact: User experience and debugging

  4. Compliance Basics (Backend)

    • Audit logging tables
    • Data deletion API
    • COPPA age verification
    • Impact: Legal requirement

  5. Testing Foundation (All)

    • Unit test coverage 80%+
    • Integration tests for APIs
    • CI/CD pipeline
    • Impact: Code quality

High Priority (Pre-Launch)

  1. AI Safety Features (Backend)

    • Medical disclaimer triggers
    • Prompt injection protection
    • Response moderation
    • Impact: User safety

  2. Real-Time Sync (Backend + Frontend)

    • WebSocket room management
    • Family activity sync
    • Presence indicators
    • Impact: Core collaboration feature

  3. Accessibility (Frontend)

    • Screen reader support
    • Keyboard navigation
    • WCAG AA compliance
    • Impact: Legal requirement

  4. Localization (Frontend)

    • i18n setup for 5 languages
    • Date/time/unit localization
    • Impact: International users

  5. Monitoring & Logging (Infrastructure)

    • Sentry integration
    • Structured logging
    • Performance metrics
    • Impact: Production operations

Medium Priority (Post-Launch)

  1. GraphQL API (Backend)

    • GraphQL endpoint
    • Schema design
    • Complex queries
    • Impact: Performance optimization

  2. Voice Processing (Backend)

    • Whisper integration
    • Intent classification
    • Entity extraction
    • Impact: Hands-free feature

  3. Analytics & Predictions (Backend)

    • Pattern detection
    • ML-based predictions
    • Automated insights
    • Impact: Value-add features

  4. PWA Features (Frontend)

    • Service worker
    • Offline pages
    • Install prompts
    • Impact: Web experience

  5. Design System (Frontend)

    • Custom components
    • Dark mode
    • Loading states
    • Impact: Polish and UX

Low Priority (Future Releases)

  1. File Storage (Backend)

    • MinIO integration
    • Image processing
    • Photo uploads
    • Impact: Nice-to-have

  2. Advanced Features (Backend)

    • Table partitioning
    • Background jobs
    • Complex reporting
    • Impact: Scale and performance

  3. Mobile Distribution (Infrastructure)

    • App Store setup
    • Play Store setup
    • OTA updates
    • Impact: Distribution (post-MVP)

7. Implementation Recommendations

Phase 1: Foundation (Weeks 1-2)

Focus: Core functionality and stability

  1. Implement offline-first Redux architecture
  2. Add comprehensive error handling with standardized codes
  3. Set up Sentry and structured logging
  4. Complete authentication security (password reset, email verification)
  5. Add COPPA/GDPR compliance basics (audit logs, data deletion)

Deliverables:

  • Offline-capable frontend
  • Secure authentication flow
  • Production-ready error handling
  • Compliance foundation

Phase 2: Real-Time & AI (Weeks 3-4)

Focus: Collaboration and intelligence

  1. Implement WebSocket family sync
  2. Add AI safety features (medical disclaimers, prompt protection)
  3. Enhance AI with context management and conversation memory
  4. Add voice processing basics (Whisper, intent classification)
  5. Implement real-time activity notifications

Deliverables:

  • Family real-time collaboration
  • Safe and contextual AI responses
  • Voice-to-text activity logging

Phase 3: Polish & Testing (Weeks 5-6)

Focus: Quality and accessibility

  1. Achieve 80% unit test coverage
  2. Add integration and E2E tests
  3. Implement accessibility features (WCAG AA)
  4. Add localization for 5 languages
  5. Implement PWA features (service worker, offline)
  6. Set up CI/CD pipeline

Deliverables:

  • Comprehensive test suite
  • Accessible application
  • Multi-language support
  • Automated deployments

Phase 4: Enhancement (Weeks 7-8)

Focus: Performance and user experience

  1. Add GraphQL endpoint for complex queries
  2. Implement analytics and predictions
  3. Add design system polish (dark mode, loading states)
  4. Optimize database with indexes and caching
  5. Implement rate limiting and security hardening

Deliverables:

  • Performant API
  • Predictive insights
  • Polished UI/UX
  • Hardened security

8. Conclusion

Summary Statistics

  • Total Gaps Identified: 120 features
    • Completed: 30 features ✅ (25%)
    • Remaining: 90 features
  • Critical Priority: 18 features (8 completed ✅)
  • High Priority: 35 features (16 completed ✅)
  • Medium Priority: 42 features (6 completed ✅)
  • Low Priority: 25 features (0 completed)

Key Observations

  1. Strong Foundation: The core architecture is well-implemented with proper modules, entities, and page structure.

  2. Recent Progress (October 2025): ✅

    • Photo management system with MinIO integration
    • Comprehensive error code system with multi-language support
    • Redis caching infrastructure
    • Performance monitoring and database optimization
    • Audit logging for compliance
    • Rate limiting with 5 endpoint configurations
    • Prompt injection protection with 25+ security patterns
    • Voice intent classification with entity extraction
    • Loading states with 15+ skeleton components
    • Password reset and email verification flows
    • Email service with Mailgun integration
    • Multi-Factor Authentication (TOTP + Email)
    • Biometric authentication (WebAuthn/FIDO2)
    • Session management with revocation
    • Device trust management system
    • Offline-first Redux architecture (sync queue, optimistic updates, conflict resolution)
    • Daily summary dashboard (October 2): Real activity counts with medicine tracker
    • Activities history page (October 2): 7-day activity timeline view
    • Sleep duration tracking (October 2): Automatic duration calculation from start/end times

  3. Missing Critical Features: Compliance features (COPPA/GDPR) and testing are the most critical remaining gaps.

  4. AI Needs Work: The AI module exists but lacks safety features, context management, and multi-language support.

  5. Testing Needed: Jest is configured but no tests have been written. This is a significant technical debt.

  6. Accessibility Gaps: No evidence of accessibility testing or screen reader support.

  7. Security Hardening: Strong authentication system ✅ (MFA, biometric, session management, device trust), error handling improved ✅, rate limiting implemented ✅, prompt injection protection added ✅, but still needs comprehensive input validation and CORS configuration.

Next Steps

  1. Implement compliance features - Legal requirement for launch (COPPA/GDPR data export/deletion, consent management)
  2. Write tests - Critical for code quality and maintainability (currently 0% coverage, target 80%)
  3. Add accessibility features - Legal requirement and good practice (WCAG AA compliance, screen readers, keyboard nav)
  4. Configure Redux Persist - State persistence across page reloads (dependencies installed but not configured)
  5. Frontend UI for auth features - Backend complete for MFA/biometric/sessions/devices, need user-facing UI

Documentation Quality

The documentation is excellent and comprehensive. The main challenge is that the implementation has only completed about 30-40% of the documented features. The project needs focused implementation effort on the critical gaps identified in this document.

Document Version: 1.0 Last Updated: October 1, 2024 Maintained By: Implementation Team

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink